How Do I Get My Dog to Play Fetch? (Vet Answered)
This question has been answered by a vet
Veterinarian & Animal Behaviorist
With nearly two decades in veterinary medicine, Dr. Paola brings hands-on experience across multiple species. A graduate of the University of Guadalajara, she specializes in preventive care, animal welfare, and positive reinforcement training.
The Question
“Hi Dr. Paola,
Tiger brings me his toys, and when I take them to throw them and play fetch, he looks devastated, but I’m not sure what else to do with the toys he keeps bringing to me. Could he be just wanting to show them off? He retrieves them and brings them back to me, and I toss them again, but I get the sad puppy dog eyes when I do it. But I’m just not sure what else to do!“ – Teresa
Quick Info about Tiger
Hi Teresa,
That’s a lovely observation, and it sounds like Tiger is trying to communicate something more nuanced than a simple game of fetch. Many dogs, especially retrievers or those with strong social bonds, bring their toys as a way of sharing rather than initiating a high-energy game. In Tiger’s case, those “sad eyes” may reflect disappointment because his goal might not be to chase but to engage in a moment of connection. By taking the toy and throwing it, you might be unintentionally missing the social part of his offering, which to him could feel like a rejection of his “gift.”
You can test this by changing the interaction. When Tiger brings you a toy, instead of immediately throwing it, gently praise him, speak softly, and pet him while he still holds the toy. Try engaging in light tug play or simply admire his toy with enthusiasm. Some dogs enjoy sitting beside their person, chewing, or showing off their toy while being praised. If you observe that he relaxes and looks content rather than disappointed, you’ve found what he was really asking for: shared attention and affirmation rather than a fetch session.
In short, Tiger’s behavior reflects a social offering, not necessarily a request for action. By slowing down and recognizing his intent, you’re helping strengthen your bond and honoring the emotional depth dogs express through play.
Best,
– Dr. Paola